5 Must-Try Sandwiches in New York

Sandwiches in New York

Crafting specialty sandwiches in New York, Central Market New York stands as a beacon for sandwich lovers and culinary explorers alike.

With a menu that sings the praises of diverse flavors and high-quality ingredients, it’s a place where every dish tells a story. For those setting foot in our revered establishment for the first time, we’ve curated a list of five must-try dishes.

These selections not only embody our culinary ethos but also offer a glimpse into the soul of New York’s vibrant food scene.

1. Milano Chicken – An Italian-Inspired Specialty

Our Milano Chicken sandwich is a homage to the rich flavors of Italy.

This masterpiece starts with a perfectly marinated grilled chicken breast, imbued with herbs and spices that dance on your palate. Layered with succulent roasted red peppers and creamy fresh mozzarella, each component complements the other flawlessly.

But the real star is our homemade pesto, bringing a burst of Italian flair. Encased in a toasted ciabatta that offers a satisfying crunch, this sandwich is not just a meal; it’s a journey through Italy.

2. Smoked Turkey and Jarlsberg Cheese with Plum Tomatoes – A Classic Combination

Simplicity meets sophistication in our Smoked Turkey and Jarlsberg Cheese sandwich.

The smoked turkey, known for its tender texture and smoky undertones, pairs exquisitely with the Jarlsberg cheese, whose nutty and slightly sweet notes create a symphony of flavors.

The addition of fresh, juicy plum tomatoes adds a burst of freshness, cutting through the richness of the meat and cheese. Pressed to perfection on a ciabatta, this sandwich offers a delightful interplay of textures, from the crispy crust to the soft, warm interior.

It’s a testament to how classic ingredients can create an extraordinary culinary experience.

3. Scarsdale – A Delightful Fusion

The Scarsdale is a sandwich that defies convention, blending sweet and savory elements to create something truly unique. At its heart is the honey maple turkey, a meat that’s both succulent and sweet. This is complemented by the melted Swiss cheese, which adds a layer of creamy indulgence.

The plum tomatoes provide a tangy contrast, while our homemade honey mustard introduces a subtle kick, elevating the sandwich to new heights. Served on butter-grilled multigrain bread, the Scarsdale is not just a sandwich; it’s a culinary adventure, offering a taste that’s both familiar and excitingly new.

4. Classic BLT – An All-Time Favorite

Our Classic BLT is a testament to the power of traditional flavors done right.

We start with thick slices of Applewood smoked bacon, known for its deep, rich flavor and perfect crispiness. This is paired with fresh hearts of romaine lettuce and ripe plum tomatoes, adding a refreshing crunch and juiciness.

But what truly sets our BLT apart is the homemade herb mayonnaise, a creamy and flavorful addition that ties all the elements together. Served on toasted hearty white bread, this sandwich is a celebration of classic tastes, proving that sometimes, the simplest things are the most satisfying.

5. Buffalo Chicken – A Spicy Delight

For those who crave a bit of heat, our Buffalo Chicken sandwich is a must-try.

This sandwich features a crispy chicken cutlet, perfectly dipped in our zesty buffalo sauce, offering just the right amount of spice. The heat is balanced with crisp romaine lettuce and fresh plum tomatoes, adding a refreshing crunch.

But what truly sets this sandwich apart is our homemade bleu cheese dressing, a creamy and tangy complement that cools the palate. Served on a toasted Parker roll, this sandwich is a harmonious blend of spicy, savory, and cool – a true delight for spice lovers.


At Central Market New York, our passion for crafting exceptional culinary experiences is evident in every dish we serve. These five sandwiches are just the beginning of what we have to offer, each one a testament to our commitment to quality, flavor, and innovation.

Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a long-time patron, we invite you to indulge in these culinary creations and discover the essence of New York’s diverse and vibrant food culture.

Central Market New York isn’t just a place to eat; it’s a destination where every meal is an exploration and every bite a new discovery.

Share This :

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Featured News

Join our newsletter and get 10% off your first online order!

Get 10% off

Get 10% off your next purchase when you subscribe to our newsletter. Don’t miss our special promos and the latest on our artisan sandwiches!